Pre-Seed Startups: 5 HR Mistakes to Avoid to Keep Your Top Talents

nahc.io team
April 25, 2025
3
min read

Building a pre-seed startup is a high-stakes journey. Your earliest hires are critical to your future success.

However, many founders make avoidable HR mistakes that can drive away top talent just when you need them most. Here are five common pitfalls and how to steer clear of them to ensure your best people stay engaged and committed.

Overlooking Competitive Compensation and Benefits

Startups often operate with tight budgets. Failing to offer competitive salaries and benefits is a surefire way to lose top talent to better-funded competitors.

Even if you can’t match the paychecks of larger companies, your compensation packages must align with market rates. Include meaningful benefits such as health insurance, retirement plans, and flexible work arrangements.

Creative perks and equity can supplement cash compensation.

Stacked coins with upward arrow blocks symbolizing growth.
Beyond cash: equity and perks drive compensation forward.

Neglecting Company Culture and Employee Experience

In the rush to build products and chase growth, founders sometimes overlook the importance of company culture.

From day one, prioritize a culture of transparency, recognition, and inclusivity. Regular feedback, clear communication, and celebrating achievements help foster a sense of belonging and purpose.

Remember, your early hires set the tone for everyone who follows.

Hiring in Haste or for the Wrong Reasons

It’s tempting to hire quickly—especially friends or acquaintances—to fill urgent gaps. However, weak hiring practices and bringing on the wrong people can be disastrous.

Avoid shortcuts. Define roles clearly, assess candidates for both skills and cultural fit, and don’t skip structured interviews.

Hiring friends without due diligence can strain relationships and harm your business if they’re not the right fit. Take the time to build a team that shares your vision and values.

Failing to Invest in Growth and Development

Top talent wants to grow. If you don’t provide opportunities for learning, mentorship, and career advancement, your best people will look elsewhere.

Even at the pre-seed stage, offer access to training, encourage skill development, and create clear pathways for progression.

Team collaborating on skill development strategies.
Early-stage startups thrive on growth and learning.

Ignoring Compliance and Proper HR Processes

Trying to “wing it” with HR can backfire. Misclassifying employees, mishandling payroll, or failing to comply with labor laws can result in costly penalties and erode trust.

Even in a small team, set up basic HR processes. Proper contracts, clear policies, and accurate payroll systems are essential. Seek expert advice if needed.

Getting these fundamentals right protects both your business and your employees.

Building a strong foundation for retention requires more than avoiding mistakes. It’s about creating a workplace where top talent feels valued and motivated to stay.

By offering fair compensation, nurturing a strong culture, hiring thoughtfully, supporting development, and maintaining solid HR practices, you can build a resilient team. This team will help your startup thrive through every stage of growth.


Reach out to our Talent Advisors
to discuss your recruitment and HR needs. Let us help you build a strong team and establish yourself as a standout employer in the market.